The problems with and why the Enochian calendar doesn’t line up with the Torah
Greg Witter | Ephraim’s Cry
Hebraic Mindset Study Series
The Astronomical Book in 1 Enoch and Its Misalignment with Biblical Scripture
The Astronomical Book, also known as The Book of the Heavenly Luminaries (Chapters 72–82), is one of the most complex sections of 1 Enoch. It details the movements of celestial bodies such as the sun, moon, and stars, describing their roles in maintaining the proper calendar for religious observances. The angel Uriel instructs Enoch in these astronomical secrets, revealing the intricate workings of the heavens. However, despite its emphasis on the importance of maintaining a divinely-ordered calendar, the Astronomical Book departs from the instructions and principles set forth in the Torah, particularly regarding the biblical calendar and the observance of Elohim/God’s appointed times.
Here are several key areas where the Astronomical Book does not align with the scriptural instructions regarding the biblical calendar and new year.
1. The Solar Calendar vs. The Lunar-Solar Calendar
In the Astronomical Book, 1 Enoch promotes a solar calendar of 364 days, which is divided into four seasons, each comprising 91 days. This calendar system gives precedence to the movements of the sun, and the text strongly critiques any calendar that incorporates lunar cycles. The text emphasizes the importance of disregarding the moon when calculating time for religious observances, claiming that this is the proper divine order revealed to Enoch.
However, the biblical calendar as outlined in Scripture is a lunar-solar calendar, meaning it incorporates both the cycles of the sun and the moon. The Torah establishes that the months are determined by the phases of the moon, and the festivals are tied to specific lunar events. For example:
New Moon Observances: The beginning of each month in the biblical calendar is determined by the appearance of the new moon, an observance Elohim/God commanded to the Israelites. Numbers 10:10 and Psalm 81:3 emphasize the significance of the new moon as a time for the blowing of trumpets and setting apart holy convocations.
Passover and the Feast of Unleavened Bread: These festivals are timed according to the moon. The Passover is observed on the 14th day of the first month (Nisan) at the full moon (Exodus 12:6). The Feast of Unleavened Bread follows immediately after and is tied to this lunar-based timing.
The Biblical Year Begins in Spring: In Exodus 12:2, Elohim/God commands that the month of Abib (Nisan), when the barley ripens, is the beginning of the biblical year. This timing is determined by both the agricultural cycle and the lunar cycle, as the new moon closest to the spring equinox signals the start of the new year.
By promoting a purely solar calendar, the Astronomical Book diverges from these fundamental biblical instructions. The exclusion of the moon in timekeeping directly contradicts Scriptures that clearly integrate lunar cycles into the reckoning of sacred times.
2. The Fixed Number of Days in a Year
In the Astronomical Book, the year is fixed at 364 days, with no variation. This contrasts with the biblical calendar, where the length of the year can vary slightly to ensure alignment with both the lunar cycles and the agricultural seasons, particularly the barley harvest.
The biblical year is based on the lunar cycle, which is approximately 354 days long, 10 or 11 days shorter than the solar year. To reconcile the lunar and solar years, an extra month (Adar II) is added periodically (usually every two or three years) to bring the calendar back in sync with the solar cycle and the agricultural cycle. This process is called intercalation.
In Deuteronomy 16:1, the Israelites are commanded to keep the Passover in the month of Abib, when the barley is ripe. This requires the calendar to adjust periodically to ensure that the festivals occur in their appropriate seasons.
The biblical calendar’s flexibility is a crucial aspect of covenantal faithfulness, ensuring that the appointed times—such as Passover, Sukkot, and Shavuot—are celebrated according to both the lunar cycle and the agricultural reality of the land.
The rigid structure of the 364-day calendar in 1 Enoch does not account for these necessary adjustments and would result in the misalignment of festivals with their biblical timing. Over time, the seasons and appointed times would drift out of sync with the agricultural cycles and Elohim/God’s instructions.
3. The Role of the Moon in Biblical Timekeeping
1 Enoch downplays the role of the moon, even portraying it as misleading compared to the more reliable solar cycles. This is in sharp contrast to the Torah, where the moon plays an essential role in the timing of religious observances.
In Psalm 104:19, it is written, “He made the moon to mark the seasons.” The Hebrew word for “seasons” here is moedim (מוֹעֲדִים), which also means appointed times or festivals. The moon is thus directly connected to the timing of Yahweh’s holy convocations.
The Feast of Trumpets (Yom Teruah) is observed on the first day of the seventh month, which is marked by the appearance of the new moon (Leviticus 23:24). This day is set apart specifically because it coincides with the renewal of the moon.
In the biblical view, the moon’s phases are crucial for determining the timing of sacred events, whereas 1 Enoch suggests that reliance on the moon leads to error and is less reliable than the sun. This de-emphasis of the moon stands in opposition to scriptural commands that place the moon at the center of Israel’s timekeeping and religious observance.
4. New Year and Agricultural Cycles in the Bible vs. 1 Enoch
The Torah clearly links the biblical New Year with agricultural cycles, particularly the ripening of the barley in the month of Abib (Exodus 12:2, Deuteronomy 16:1). The timing of the biblical New Year is not simply a celestial event but is deeply tied to the land and its produce, which reflects the covenant relationship between Elohim/God and Israel.
The Month of Abib (Nisan) marks the beginning of the year because it is the time when the barley crop is ready for harvest. The New Year is not determined solely by solar or lunar calculations but also by this physical, agricultural sign (Exodus 9:31, Deuteronomy 16:1).
In contrast, the Astronomical Book’s 364-day solar calendar ignores the agricultural markers that are foundational to the biblical reckoning of time. By focusing exclusively on celestial bodies, 1 Enoch neglects the agricultural aspect of the biblical calendar that ensures festivals such as Passover, First Fruits, and Shavuot are celebrated in their proper seasons according to the harvest.
5. Prophetic Warnings Against Altering Elohim/God’s Times
The Bible contains prophetic warnings against altering Elohim/God’s established times and seasons. For example, in Daniel 7:25, the prophetic vision warns about a power that will “intend to change times and law.” This could be seen as a reference to those who would attempt to alter Elohim/God’s established calendar, which includes His Sabbath, new moons, and festivals.
Isaiah 1:13-14 also expresses Elohim/God’s displeasure with the misuse of the appointed times, where the people are performing outward observances but disregarding their true spiritual meaning. The improper observance of these times is seen as spiritual disobedience, a principle that could be applied to those who follow an incorrect calendar, such as the solar-only system proposed by 1 Enoch.
By proposing a calendar that deviates from the lunar-solar system given in the Torah, 1 Enoch could be seen as violating Elohim/God’s established order. The scriptural calendar is divinely revealed and tied to both the natural world and covenantal obligations, whereas the 364-day solar calendar is a speculative and human-devised system that ultimately leads to the misalignment of sacred times.
Conclusion
While 1 Enoch provides an intricate description of the heavens and the celestial bodies, its 364-day solar calendar conflicts with the lunar-solar system prescribed in the Torah. The biblical calendar, which is based on both the cycles of the moon and the sun, ensures that the appointed times—such as Passover, Sukkot, and the Sabbaths—are aligned with the natural and agricultural seasons as commanded by Elohim/God. The Astronomical Book’s exclusion of the moon, its rigid year structure, and its disregard for agricultural cycles depart from the divine order established in the Torah, leading to a misrepresentation of the biblical approach to timekeeping and the observance of sacred events. This misalignment illustrates why 1 Enoch, while valuable for understanding Second Temple Hebraic thought, cannot be regarded as authoritative or divinely inspired in matters of the biblical calendar.
#BookOfEnoch#HebraicPerspective#BiblicalCalendar#TorahTruth#LunarSolarCalendar#HebraicRoots
#ScripturalAuthority#Elohim
#DivineOrder#BiblicalFestivals#SecondTempleJudaism#BiblicalTimekeeping#AppointedTimes#Nephilim
#Watchers#Ephraimscry#GregWitter
